Monday, 20 November 2017


Following on from my earlier post, Move up the Value Chain and be Less Employable this The Malaysian Insight article provides deeper insights into a major aspect of the problems contributing to graduate unemployment.

At least in my earlier commentary on this issue referred to, there were some Malaysian graduates, including engineering graduates who to their credit were willing to take up cleaning jobs normally done by foreign workers (indentured wage slaves), which few Malaysians today are willing to do. Several years back I covered the online employment agency Jobstreet's media conference about the state of employment and  learned that some information technology (IT) graduates who were on Jobstreet were very choosy and refused to take jobs opportunities for which they were suited simply because it was not their "ideal" job.

So whilst these graduates waited for their 'ideal' job to come along, their indulgent parents were willing to support them and as a result, some of them had been unemployed for over a year.

I can relate to what Skim Latihan 1Malaysia organiser Norashikin Ismail who calls the current stock of young graduates the ‘strawberry generation’, who will up and quit when they are told off for doing their jobs badly.
Some will show up for three days, and then run off. If they get told off by their bosses, they will run off," she told The Malaysian Insight.

My friend and neighbour has a small company which packs and markets medical examination gloves under his own brand name and needed some additional workers to pack gloves.

Another neighbour, a taxi driver living nearby his workplace had asked him to employ his two boys, both unemployed school leavers, so he offered them jobs but they just did not turn up for work.

He managed to get a worker, a school leaver who had completed his SPM (Malaysian Certificate of Education) from a welfare home for teenage boys and this person worked for about three or so days and did not turn up for work after that.

From what I was told, this young man was frequently taking and receiving calls on his phone during working hours and when he was told not to use his phone during working hours, except during breaks, he started to visit the toilet very frequently during working hours, presumably to use his phone.

So it appears that unable to use his phone during working hours, he stopped turning up for work.

If this is the attitude of a young man from a welfare home, then what more the attitude of those young people with rich parents who let him stay at home for free, indulge them with the latest and 'greatest' smartphone every six months, give them all the pocket money to spend on expensive lattes whilst hanging out with friends in hip, hype, happening and cool chain cafes, who throw in a car as well and have a bevy of maids to do everything for them, including wipe and  wash their bums for them after they defaecate.

I've also heard complaints by public relations companies about the entitlement mentality amongst Gen Y and Millennial staff who have such a high opinion of themselves and their capabilities, even before they have proven themselves in their work.

Well, this is Malaysia's pampered and spoiled generation - the much touted "Generation Y" and "Millennials" generation - the Internet Generation - most of whom go around with faces buried in their and tablet devices, who know social media backwards but do not know how to write a proper job application.

Welcome to that much touted "Knowledge-based, Information and Services Society" and to the "Internet Generation" who are Malaysia's "future".

Remember. The Roman Empire declined and fell after the Roman elite grew too dependent on their slaves to do everything for them, whilst they (the Roman elite) indulged in several days long feasts where they ate and drank till they were full, induced themselves to vomit out the food and drink they had consumed right where they sat and had their slave crawl under the table wiping up the mess on the floor below them.

"That's not to say the Romans were unfamiliar with throwing up, or that they never did so on purpose. On the contrary, in ancient times vomiting seems to have been a standard part of the fine-dining experience. In his Moral Epistles the Roman philosopher Seneca writes, Cum ad cenandum discubuimus, alius sputa deterget, alius reliquias temulentorum [toro] subditus colligit, "When we recline at a banquet, one [slave] wipes up the spittle; another, situated beneath [the table], collects the leavings of the drunks." OK, it doesn't literally say puke, but come on. The orator Cicero, in Pro Rege Deiotaro, says matter-of-factly that Julius Caesar "expressed a desire to vomit after dinner"(vomere post cenam te velle dixisses), and elsewhere suggests that the dictator took emetics for this purpose."

Whilst many Malaysians do gluttonously gorge, we aren't quite as decadent as the ancient Roman elite - well at least not yet.

The Malaysian Insight article follows below.

Yours Trully



Bad attitude, not lack of skill, is jobless graduates’ biggest hurdle

The Malaysian Insight

Yasmin Ramlan Updated 7 hours ago · Published on 20 Nov 2017 7:00AM ·

Bad attitude, not lack of skill, is jobless graduates’ biggest hurdle Skim Latihan 1Malaysia organiser Norashikin Ismail calls the current stock of young graduates the ‘strawberry generation’, who will up and quit when they are told off for doing their jobs badly. – The Malaysian Insight pic by Seth Akmal, November 20, 2017. FOR many out-of-work graduates, a spoilt attitude and unrealistic expectations are the main impediments to them getting employed, a training and job placement programme organiser said.

A high dropout rate of graduates who signed up for Skim Latihan 1Malaysia (SL1M) showed the problem with most of the jobless youth was not a lack of skill, but bad work ethics and attitudes, said programme organiser Norashikin Ismail.

“Some will show up for three days, and then run off. If they get told off by their bosses, they will run off," she told The Malaysian Insight.

“They are all from the ‘strawberry generation’... when they don’t do their jobs well and their bosses tell them off, they take offence. 

"They are very proud to be graduates, but they don’t want to do the work,” she said.

SL1M is a programme launched by the government in 2011. It aims to help unemployed graduates, especially those with a low-income background or who are from rural areas, by placing them in companies where they are learn new skills and know-how so that they have a better chance of securing a job.

Private companies that are awarded government contracts are required to contribute 1% of the sum they earn from the contracts to fund the programme.

Set up under the Economic Planning Unit within the Prime Minister’s Department, the programme is run by 16 volunteers.

Graduates are placed as trainees for six months to a year in selected government-linked companies and private corporations, which treat the programme as a corporate social responsibility (CSR) initiative.

The graduates receive an allowance of RM1,500 during the training.

Norashikin said many of the graduates expected to be employed afterwards by the companies where they underwent training, but most of them failed to meet even the most minimum of expectations.

“If you don’t show initiative, and don’t add value to the organisation, why would they give you a job?” she said, to explain why many graduates failed to be absorbed into the companies upon completion of their training.

Lack of skill 'easier' problem to fix  

Norashikin said while some of the jobless graduates clearly exhibited a lack of training and skill set, the bulk of the graduates were simply too lazy and demanding.

“To change their attitudes and thinking is a challenge for us, because that’s really up to them,” she said, adding that some trainees would even demand a higher allowance during training.

She said graduates who lacked skill, training and confidence were “easier” problems to fix.

“There are those who are poor, unattractive, unable to speak English. But if they have a positive mindset, it is easy to polish them up.”

As of October, 138,398 graduates have enrolled in the programme and have been placed have in companies nationwide.

The data on the number of trainees dropping out mid-programme was unavailable, said Norashikin.

Former SL1M trainee Wan Nurhusna Auni Sulaiman said many of her peers, who were jobless, thought she was foolish to sign up for the programme when she already had a job.

But the 25-year-old said she was keen to enhance her resume and wanted the opportunity to work in a larger corporation or GLC.

“I was willing to leave my industry. I was working in a small company as a programmer, but after two months, I realised the company was not stable.

“So I quit and joined the SL1M programme because I wanted to learn and get a better opportunity.”

Many of her friends, who remain unemployed, were not interested in joining her as they said there was no guarantee of a job after training.

Dealing with quitters

Armed Forces Fund Board assistant human resources manager Illya Salehudin Jaafar recounted his experience with an SL1M trainee.

“On the first day (of training), he looked happy and positive. He said it was great to be able to join SL1M. By the third day, he had disappeared.

“But because we have a social responsibility here, we called him and kept calling until we managed to get him because we were afraid something had happened to him.

“He refused to answer the calls at first and we were very worried. But he finally answered the phone and he apologised profusely, confessing that he was not a morning person and could not wake up in time for work.

“We were speechless. We couldn’t say anything to a reason like that.”

Illya said employees had the option of starting work at 8.15am or 8.30am.

“It’s not like you have to start work at 7am. We were shocked. And it’s not like there was work pressure because he had worked only two days. We hadn’t even given him any assignment," she said.

Other graduates would submit their letters of withdrawal from the programme after a few days, stating they did not own a vehicle and therefore could not go to work.

“We are dealing with a new generation that will try out a job and if they don’t think it’s suitable, they will just quit,” said Illya. – November 20, 2017.

No comments:

Post a Comment